Given that Tolkien was Catholic, and that of so stern a cast that he worried that his creating a world in which mankind had not been nor was destined to be saved by Christ was a sin only to be cast off by destroying all he had written about it, it strains me a trifle to believe that he would have relished "The Demon Pope," by Richard Garnett. On the other hand, perhaps it is I who am po-faced, and Tolkien who might have been the first to laugh aloud...
The Devil came, and he tempted a young university student. The bargaining went so badly that the best the fiend was able to do was to offer the potential victim assistance for forty years, at the end of which time he would come and ask for one thing that lay within the student's power to grant, that thing being neither his soul nor his mind.
After careful reflection, the student agreed to the bargain.
Forty years passed, and passed very well indeed, for on the day appointed the man was Pope, and sitting in his study surrounded by those things which appeal to the learned. The Devil appeared and asked to be made Cardinal. The Pope astutely observed that it would then, upon his own death, be the fiend who would arrange matters so the he should become Pope.
The Devil explained that he would be a most exemplary Pope, who would see to it that all heathen knowledge would be destroyed, and that only priests could read and that only their breviary.
The Pope counter-offered to accompany the fiend to the infernal regions immediately, rather than see such a treasure of knowledge lost.
The Devil explained that he could not take a truly good man and further that he knew that the Pope knew such was the case.
Indeed I do, replied the man he had bargained with, which is why I face you with such composure. You wish to be a Cardinal. I shall make you Pope—
The fiend flushed eagerly.
—for twelve hours. At the end of that time, we shall confer and see if you would prefer to give up such a dignity. Further, I promise to grant you any boon within my powers which does not offend religion or morals.
The Devil was most willing, and so he took the Pope's place, and the true Pope, taking up a book of magic, retired into a secret room to while away the time.
The Devil donned the robes and trappings of office, but no sooner had he settled them comfortably upon himself than the door burst open and a group of sundry clergy came to complain of his dangerous learning. His faux-human form being weak, he was quickly bound and gagged, while his captors debated his fate. None of the proposals seemed overly pleasant.
One, more asute than the rest, suggested the matter could be settled beyond doubt by stripping their victim and looking for such signs as mark the Devil's own. They were richly rewarded for their efforts: The Holy Father had a cloven hoof for one foot. The singular thing was that, by their expressions and by the meaningful glances they gave one another, their victim appeared to have excited favorable interest.
(to be continued)